In this guide
If you've never ordered live lobster online, the experience is genuinely a little wild. You place an order Monday morning, the lobster gets pulled from a coastal Maine trap that afternoon, and Wednesday a styrofoam cooler arrives on your doorstep with a live, kicking, banded lobster inside. The whole supply chain is built around overnight shipping; the price reflects it; the experience is worth it at least once.
Below, twelve Maine seafood operations worth ordering from — sorted by what you actually want from them.
The biggest and most recognizable of the direct-to-consumer Maine lobster shippers. Get Maine Lobster ships live lobster nationwide from their Yarmouth facility — founder Mark Murrell launched the brand in 2009 and has since become the default for first-time online lobster buyers. Strong gifting infrastructure, frequent promotions.
Maine Lobster Now is the other big direct-to-consumer shipper, headquartered in Saco. Aggressive pricing on bulk orders — worth comparing if you're feeding a crowd.
Cape Porpoise Lobster ships from one of Maine's most picturesque working harbors. Family-owned, smaller operation than the giants above, with a slightly more personal feel.
Famously the Shark Tank-funded national brand, but Cousins still ships fresh Maine lobster directly from Portland. Worth knowing they have national food-truck retail too — if there's one near you, it's a great alternative to overnight shipping.
MUA Lobster is a newer entrant focused on direct-from-the-boat sourcing and transparent, market-based pricing. Worth a look if you want to support a smaller operation than the giants.
The chef's choice. Founded in 1991 on Portland's working waterfront, Browne Trading supplies caviar, fresh seafood, and on-site smoked fish to elite restaurants nationwide — plus a retail market and online ordering. If you want to recreate a fine-dining experience at home, this is the address. Their caviar selection is legitimately the best in the Northeast.
The icon of Portland's working waterfront. Harbor Fish on Custom House Wharf has been running since 1966 and is the kind of place where chefs from around the country place phone orders. Online shipping is solid; the in-person experience is its own pilgrimage.
SoPo is the working-waterfront retail counterpart in South Portland — fresh fish, shellfish, and prepared foods. Their online shop ships nationwide and the curation is strong.
Hancock specializes in heat-and-eat gourmet lobster gifts — lobster mac and cheese, lobster bisque, lobster pot pies. Easier than dealing with live lobster yourself; perfect as a gift.
The lobster roll chain that scaled. Luke's ships their signature roll kits nationwide — top-split bun, butter, cooked claw and knuckle meat — a low-effort version of the Maine roll experience.
Maine's largest kelp aquaculture company. Atlantic Sea Farms partners with Maine lobstermen who grow kelp in the off-season as a sustainable side income. Their fermented sea-greens kimchi and ready-cut kelp products are worth seeking out.
Heritage is the Portland-based source for hand-harvested Maine sea vegetables — dulse, kelp, alaria, sea lettuce. Useful for cooks ready to expand beyond standard seafood proteins.
For a first lobster order, Get Maine Lobster is the easiest entry point. For a chef-grade special-occasion experience, Browne Trading. For a low-effort gift, Hancock or Luke's. For something genuinely different, Atlantic Sea Farms or Heritage Seaweed. And if you can drive to Portland, just walk into Harbor Fish or SoPo and pick something up in person — it'll always taste better than what shipped overnight.
For more Maine makers, explore the full Grocery & Food category on Maine Open Online.
.png){kind=logo}
